Upon our recent vacation, I had the chance to read five books given me by a certain literary sister, and after perusing them, I thought it would be great fun to review them. Four of the books were written by Georgette Heyer and were my first introduction to that lady's work. The other was called, 'Shh, We Have a Plan' by Chris Haughton. What do four regency romance novels have to do with a child's board book? Absolutely nothing! Which is what makes this review so much fun.
I am a huge Jane Austen fan; I enjoy all her books, but Pride and Prejudice is by far my favorite. I have read various sequels and adaptations over the years, but nothing has come close, a most are downright pathetic. Georgette Heyer is assumed by many to be Austen's heir and has written over 40 books, many taking place during the Regency period of England in which Austen's books are set. This was my first exposure to her work; I've seen her books around, indeed they are ubiquitous, but I never bothered to pick one up. My sister loaned me four of her favorites and I actually had a little time on our trip, so why not?
Heyer is a gifted writer, there are some very amusing scenes, intriguing characters, interesting plots, and the dialogue is upbeat, at least in the first book. The problem is, all of her books are the same! I won't bother listing the titles as it really doesn't matter. She has basically boiled Pride and Prejudice down to its constituent parts then fleshes out the bare bones with slightly varying details, but it quickly grows old and none of her books are of the same caliber as Austen's classic. They are an amusing, fluffy read on vacation, but nothing I am going to put on my shelf to read over again.
Heyer in a nutshell: a rich, fashionable man, bored and cynical of women in particular and life in general (he must dress perfectly, wear very shiny hessian boots, have an immaculate neckcloth, and drive a team to precision) meets a comely lady, who is the only female on the planet not out to win his hand. He is intrigued by said damsel, or perhaps by the novelty of a woman not immediately in love with him, and they fall into some sort of scrape or adventure together and he eventually proposes. She must inevitably refuse his offer of marriage at least once because she cannot imagine he actually loves her. After about 10 more pages, the misunderstanding is corrected and she accepts him and the book ends. The heroine of course must be virtuous, intrepid, and have an arch sense of humor, but she is not grasping nor does she think very highly of herself, yet she must be confident and just in her dealings with all others.
Strange as it may sound, some of my favorite books are actually composed of fewer than 10 pages and 100 words. I had a few favorite books from my childhood but was in no way a connoisseur of children's literature, but now having kids means I get a second chance to peruse this oft overlooked genre. I was delighted by Sandra Boynton and enjoy many of the 'Little Critter' books immensely, though I am having second thoughts about Dr. Seuss in my waning years. Many children's books are either dull or focused too much on educational matters or are dumbed down to the point of insult; a good children's story is none of these. This little book was absolutely delightful!
The long and the short of it: we'll be reading 'Shh, We Have a Plan,' for years to come. If you've read one Heyer regency romance, you've read them all.
No comments:
Post a Comment